Evaluating your trading plan is like maintaining a car – you need regular checks to ensure everything runs smoothly. Markets change, and strategies that worked before may no longer deliver results. Here’s what you need to know:
- Why Review Your Trading Plan
- Markets evolve due to economic shifts, sentiment changes, or updates from exchanges like the Singapore Exchange.
- Regular reviews ensure your plan aligns with your financial goals and risk tolerance.
- Track Key Metrics
- Win Rate: Percentage of profitable trades.
- Profit Factor: Total profits divided by total losses (aim for above 1.0).
- Average Profit vs Loss: Ensures your gains offset losses.
- Maximum Drawdown: Tracks the biggest drop in your account value.
- Use a Trading Journal
- Log entry/exit points, position sizes, reasoning, and emotional state.
- Add notes on market conditions and include chart screenshots.
- Backtest and Forward Test
- Backtest using historical data to identify strengths and weaknesses.
- Forward test in real-time (demo accounts) to validate the strategy.
- Refine Rules and Risk Management
- Review entry/exit rules to match current market conditions.
- Set clear risk limits: e.g., risk 1–2% of your account per trade.
- Adjust position sizing based on volatility or fixed percentages.
- Continuous Improvement
- Regularly assess performance and learn from mistakes.
- Use tools and resources like trading courses or books to stay updated.
Tip: Treat your trading plan as a “living document” that evolves with your experience and market changes. Regular reviews and disciplined execution are key to long-term success.
Tracking and Analysing Trade Performance
Evaluating your trading performance goes beyond just looking at net profits or losses. Without proper tracking, it’s impossible to identify what’s working, what’s not, or where adjustments are needed. Think of tracking as your trading compass, guiding you to make informed decisions and improve your results.
Let’s dive into the metrics that help you measure and refine your trading performance.
Key Metrics for Performance Review
Tracking specific metrics regularly is crucial for improving your trading strategy over time.
Win rate is the percentage of trades that end in profit. For instance, if you win 6 out of 10 trades, your win rate is 60%. But don’t be fooled – a high win rate doesn’t always mean you’re making money. For example, you could win 70% of your trades but still incur losses if your losing trades are significantly larger than your winning ones.
Profit factor compares your total profits to your total losses. A profit factor above 1.0 indicates overall profitability. For instance, if your total profits are S$5,000 and your total losses are S$3,000, your profit factor would be 1.67.
Average profit versus average loss helps you see if your winning trades are enough to offset your losing ones. For example, if your average winning trade earns you S$200, while your average losing trade costs you S$150, your risk-reward ratio is 1.33:1. With a ratio like this, you could still turn a profit even with a 50% win rate.
Maximum drawdown measures the largest drop in your account value from peak to trough. For example, if your account falls from S$10,000 to S$8,500, your maximum drawdown is 15%. This metric not only shows the financial impact but also highlights the emotional strain your strategy might place on you.
Using a Trading Journal
A trading journal is more than just a record of numbers – it captures the nuances that metrics alone might miss. Log every trade, including entry and exit points, position sizes (in Singapore dollars), your reasoning for the trade, and even your emotional state. This habit provides valuable insights for refining your strategy.
When documenting, include details about market conditions at the time of entry – like an upward trend in the Straits Times Index (STI) or periods of high volatility. Adding screenshots of your charts at entry and exit points can also help you spot patterns that written notes might overlook.
Track your emotional state during trades. Whether you felt confident, anxious, or impulsive, these notes can reveal emotional triggers that lead to poor decisions. For example, you might notice a tendency to take oversized risks after a loss or to exit winning trades too early due to nervousness.
“Regular performance reviews through trade journal analysis help identify patterns and refine strategy elements based on concrete data rather than emotions.”
- Trade with the Pros
Regular Performance Reviews
Weekly reviews strike a balance between staying focused and gaining insights. Use this time to calculate your win rate for different setups, measure your average profit versus average loss, and assess how you perform under various market conditions.
| Optimisation Element | Review Frequency | Key Metrics to Track |
|---|---|---|
| Entry Rules | Weekly | Win Rate, Average Entry Slippage |
| Exit Rules | Weekly | Profit Factor, Average Hold Time |
| Position Sizing | Monthly | Risk per Trade, Max Drawdown |
| Risk Parameters | Monthly | Sharpe Ratio, Recovery Factor |
When reviewing, focus on one area at a time. For instance, if you’re analysing your entry rules this week, avoid simultaneously tweaking your exit strategy. This approach ensures you can clearly measure the impact of each change.
Set measurable goals for your reviews. Instead of vague targets like “do better”, aim for specific benchmarks such as “achieve a profit factor above 1.5” or “limit maximum drawdown to under 10%.” These concrete goals make it easier to evaluate your progress.
Pay close attention to position sizing during your reviews. Even with a solid strategy, many traders fail to stick to their own risk management rules. Track how often you deviate from your planned position sizes and analyse the consequences of those deviations.
If your goals aren’t met, dig into the reasons why. Was market volatility higher than expected? Did you uncover gaps in your strategy? Understanding these factors helps you set more realistic targets and pinpoint areas for improvement.
“Remember that consistency comes from following your trading plan, maintaining emotional control, and regularly reviewing your performance.”
- Trade with the Pros
These performance reviews lay the groundwork for refining and testing your strategies further.
Backtesting and Forward Testing Your Plan
Before putting your hard-earned money on the line, it’s crucial to test your trading plan using both historical data and real-time simulations. Backtesting and forward testing each play a unique role in helping you understand how your strategy might perform in the real world.
How to Backtest Your Strategy
Backtesting involves applying your trading strategy to historical market data to see how it would have performed in the past. This step is essential for pinpointing weaknesses and estimating potential returns without risking actual money.
Start by gathering accurate and detailed historical data for your chosen markets. For instance, if you’re trading Singapore stocks, ensure the dataset includes precise price movements for the Straits Times Index (STI) components over an extended period. Be cautious of low-quality data or missing adjustments, such as stock splits or dividends, as these can distort your results.
Define clear and specific entry and exit rules. Avoid vague terms like “buy when the trend looks strong.” Instead, use measurable criteria, such as entering a trade when a short-term moving average crosses above a long-term one, coupled with a trading volume spike above its recent average.
Factor in realistic trading costs like brokerage and clearing fees, especially if your strategy involves frequent trades. These costs can significantly impact profitability.
Consistency in position sizing is also vital. Stick to a fixed percentage or set amount per trade to ensure your backtest results are reliable and not skewed by inconsistent risk levels.
Be mindful of survivorship bias. Testing only on current STI components might ignore companies that were delisted or dropped from the index. Including historical constituents can give you a more accurate picture of how your strategy might perform.
Once you’ve fine-tuned your rules through backtesting, the next step is to validate them in real-time conditions.
Forward Testing with Demo Accounts
Forward testing, often called paper trading, involves running your strategy in real-time markets but without using real money. This step helps you see how your plan holds up under live conditions.
Many brokers in Singapore offer demo accounts that mimic real trading environments. These accounts allow you to test your strategy with the same tools and market access you’d use in live trading. Stick to the same risk parameters in your demo account that you plan to use with real capital.
Pay close attention to the differences between your backtesting results and forward testing outcomes. Market conditions evolve over time, and a strategy that worked in historical data may struggle in different environments.
Use forward testing to assess execution speed, order management, and the reliability of your system. Running your test over a variety of market conditions will help you determine whether your strategy is robust enough for live trading.
Reading Test Results
When analysing your test results, don’t just focus on profit and loss. Dig deeper into metrics that reveal the durability and reliability of your strategy.
Consistency across various time periods is crucial. If your strategy excels in one market environment but struggles in another, investigate what caused those differences. A good strategy should perform reasonably well across different conditions, even if some periods are more favourable than others.
Pay close attention to drawdowns. While a strategy might be mathematically sound, significant drawdowns can be emotionally taxing when trading live. Make sure your plan can handle the worst-case scenarios uncovered during testing.
Compare your strategy’s performance to market benchmarks. If your returns fall significantly behind a major index, like the Straits Times Index, consider whether the time, effort, and risk involved in your approach are worth it.
Look for parameter sensitivity in your results. If small changes to your indicators cause dramatic shifts in performance, your strategy might be overfitted to historical data and less likely to succeed in real markets.
Finally, analyse your worst trades to find patterns. Do losses often occur under specific market conditions or share common traits? Use these insights to refine your strategy or add filters to reduce similar losses in the future.
Think about the practicality of implementing your strategy. If your system requires constant monitoring but you have other commitments, it might not be feasible. Make sure your testing reflects your real-life availability and trading habits. Document everything you learn for continuous improvement.
Reviewing and Improving Trading Rules
After conducting performance reviews and backtesting, it’s time to refine your trading rules. Regular adjustments ensure your strategies remain effective in ever-changing market conditions.
Checking Entry and Exit Rules
Take a close look at your entry and exit rules to confirm they align with the current market environment. Markets don’t stay the same – what worked during a trending phase may fail in choppy or volatile conditions.
Evaluate whether your entry points are well-timed. Are you jumping in too early or missing opportunities by hesitating? Tighten your criteria to improve precision. For instance, if your rule is to buy when a stock breaks above a resistance level, consider adding a volume confirmation to weed out false breakouts.
Exit rules are just as critical. Many traders focus too much on entries while neglecting exits, which can make or break your results. Are you cutting your winners too soon or holding onto losing trades for too long? If your average losing trade outweighs your average winner, your exit strategy needs immediate revision.
Timing also matters. For example, analyse how the first hour of trading (9:00 AM to 10:00 AM SGT) influences signal reliability for Singapore stocks. Replace any vague or emotional decision-making with clear, measurable criteria. This approach strengthens your trading plan and keeps it grounded in logic.
Adding Technical Indicators
Once your entry and exit rules are solid, consider enhancing them with a few well-chosen technical indicators. The key is to complement your strategy without overcomplicating it or introducing conflicting signals.
- Moving Averages: These are great for identifying trends and spotting support or resistance levels. If you’re currently relying on price action alone, try adding a simple moving average filter. For example, only take long trades when the price is above the 50-day moving average.
- Relative Strength Index (RSI): This can help avoid trades in overbought or oversold conditions. Adding an RSI filter might prevent buying at a peak or selling at a bottom. However, keep in mind that in strong trends, RSI can stay in extreme zones for a while.
- MACD (Moving Average Convergence Divergence): Use MACD to confirm trend shifts and momentum changes. You could pair MACD crossovers with your existing entry signals for added confirmation, but don’t rely on it as your sole trigger unless backtesting shows clear benefits.
- Volume Indicators: These provide insights that price-based indicators might miss. Unusual volume spikes often signal major price moves, while declining volume can warn of weakening trends. Integrate volume analysis into your rules for a more complete picture.
When adding indicators, test each one thoroughly. Even if an indicator works well on its own, combining it with others may lead to mixed results. Introduce one at a time, measure its impact, and ensure it improves your performance before adding another.
Testing Changes Before Going Live
Never roll out rule changes directly into live trading without rigorous testing. Even small tweaks can have a big impact on your results.
Start by backtesting your revised rules with historical data. Look at how the changes affect key metrics like win rate, average trade duration, and maximum drawdown.
Paper trading is another essential step. Test your updated strategy in real-time market conditions using a demo account for at least 20–30 trades or one month – whichever comes first. This helps you gauge how the changes feel in practice and whether they’re easy to implement consistently.
Pay close attention to execution challenges. Rules that seem simple on paper might be hard to follow in real-time trading. If your modifications demand constant monitoring or split-second decisions, ask yourself whether you can realistically maintain that level of focus.
Document every change you make, including the date, reason, and observed outcomes. This record helps you track what’s working and what isn’t. Avoid making multiple changes at once, as it becomes difficult to pinpoint which adjustments are effective.
For major changes, consider rolling them out gradually. Instead of applying new rules to your entire trading capital, start small – either with reduced position sizes or a limited number of trades. This cautious approach lets you test the waters without exposing yourself to unnecessary risk.
Finally, test your modified rules in various market conditions. A tweak that works well in trending markets might backfire in ranging ones. Understanding these trade-offs allows you to decide when to apply specific rules or whether you need separate sets of rules for different environments.
Master Systematic Trading with Collin Seow
Learn proven trading strategies, improve your market timing, and achieve financial success with our expert-led courses and resources.
Checking Your Risk Management
Once you’ve fine-tuned your entry, exit, and indicator rules, the next step is to strengthen your risk management framework. Risk management is the backbone of any successful trading strategy. Even with well-crafted trading rules, poor risk management can still result in significant losses.
Setting Risk Limits
Take a close look at your per-trade risk limits and overall exposure. A good rule of thumb is to risk only 1–2% of your account on any single trade. For example, if your trading account holds S$50,000, a 1% risk limit means you should cap your potential loss at S$500 for each trade. These limits aren’t set in stone – adjust them as your account grows or your trading style changes.
Position Sizing Methods
The way you determine position size is a key component of risk management. Here are some common methods:
| Method | How It Works | Best For | Limitations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed Percentage | Allocates a set percentage of your account per trade | Consistent strategies | Doesn’t account for market volatility |
| Volatility-Based | Adjusts position size using market volatility metrics (e.g., ATR) | Volatile instruments or markets | Requires more complex calculations |
| Fixed Dollar Amount | Risks the same dollar amount on every trade | Simplicity and small accounts | May not scale well with larger accounts |
| Kelly Criterion | Uses a formula based on win rate and payoff ratio | Experienced traders with solid data | Can sometimes suggest taking on too much risk |
For traders just starting out, the fixed percentage method is a straightforward option, especially when dealing with instruments with similar levels of volatility. On the other hand, if you’re trading in markets with significant volatility swings, a volatility-based approach can help maintain a balanced risk profile.
Updating Risk Management Rules
Your risk management rules shouldn’t be static. Regularly review and tweak them to keep pace with changing market conditions. Pay attention to correlations between the instruments in your portfolio. If correlations exceed 0.7, it could mean your portfolio is overly concentrated, and you may need to adjust your position sizes.
Incorporate a routine for monitoring risk. Check your risk parameters daily, evaluate risk-adjusted returns weekly, and conduct a thorough risk review every month. Set up real-time alerts for critical risk metrics. These ongoing adjustments will help ensure your trading strategy stays resilient as markets evolve.
Learning and Making Improvements
To succeed in trading, you need to embrace continuous learning and fine-tuning. Markets are always shifting, and staying ahead means adapting your strategies to these changes. This ongoing process is what separates consistent traders from those who struggle to find their footing.
Setting Up Regular Reviews
Establishing a consistent review schedule is key to improving your trading performance. For most traders, a monthly review works well, but if you’re trading more actively, fortnightly assessments might be better. During these reviews, dive into your trading journal, analyse your performance metrics, and consider any shifts in market conditions that could impact your approach.
Take a close look at every element of your trading plan. Are your win rates matching your backtested results? Have you stuck to your risk management rules? Did you deviate from your planned position sizes or stop-loss levels? Tailor these reviews to Singapore’s market trends, such as seasonal patterns or specific economic events.
Keep a review log to document your findings. This helps you track which adjustments lead to better results. Don’t forget to include external factors that influenced your trades, like major announcements from the Monetary Authority of Singapore or key corporate actions affecting your focus stocks.
Once you’ve reviewed your performance, shift your focus to analysing your mistakes – this is where the real learning happens.
Learning from Trading Mistakes
Every loss is a chance to learn, but only if you take the time to figure out what went wrong. For each trade, note your emotions and thought process. Were you influenced by a recent loss? Did market news or social media push you to act against your plan?
Over time, patterns will emerge. For instance, you might notice a habit of cutting profits too early during volatile sessions or increasing your position size after a winning streak. These behavioural tendencies often hurt your results more than flaws in your technical strategies.
To better understand your mistakes, create a system that categorises them. Group errors into areas like technical analysis missteps, breaches of risk management, emotional decisions, or poor timing. If you find that most of your losses stem from bad entry timing, it might be worth focusing on market structure analysis or studying volume patterns.
Maintain a decision journal to document both your actions and the reasoning behind them. This helps you differentiate between trades where your logic was sound but luck wasn’t on your side (acceptable losses) and trades that exposed flaws in your decision-making (learning opportunities).
Use what you learn from these mistakes to refine your strategies and improve your risk management.
Using Collin Seow Trading Academy Resources
The Collin Seow Trading Academy offers tools and resources that align perfectly with a disciplined approach to trading. Their educational framework is designed to eliminate emotional decision-making, which is crucial for effective plan evaluations.
The Market Timing 101 e-course is a great starting point. It provides practical techniques for improving your entry and exit timing – an area where many traders struggle. This free resource can help you identify the best points to buy and sell, which you can then test and incorporate into your strategy.
For a deeper dive, the Systematic Trader Program teaches you how to build and maintain profitable trading systems. If your reviews reveal that your current approach needs more than just minor tweaks, this program can guide you through a complete overhaul.
The academy also offers webinars and videos to keep you updated on market trends and provide ongoing education. These resources are especially helpful in maintaining the disciplined evaluation process that successful trading demands.
Finally, The Systematic Trader v.2 book is an excellent companion for your reviews. It provides detailed strategies for refining your trading plan and optimising risk management. The book’s structured methodology aligns well with the systematic approach needed to test and implement improvements effectively.
Conclusion: Building a Strong Trading Plan
Creating a solid trading plan isn’t a one-time task – it’s an ongoing journey that demands regular assessment and fine-tuning. The most successful traders understand that markets are constantly changing, and their strategies need to evolve to stay effective.
Start by focusing on three core areas: performance tracking, risk management, and strategy adjustments. Keep detailed records of every trade, noting metrics like win rates, average profits, and maximum drawdowns. This data becomes the backbone of your decision-making and future improvements.
Regular testing is essential to ensure your strategies work in changing market conditions. Singapore’s financial markets, influenced by both regional and global factors, require a tailored approach. Before committing real funds, thoroughly test any adjustments to ensure they align with the unique dynamics of these markets.
Even the most well-crafted plan can falter without consistent execution. Schedule regular reviews to ensure you’re following your plan and document any deviations. These reviews often reveal patterns in your decision-making that might need tweaking.
Staying competitive also means committing to continuous learning. As market conditions shift, updating your knowledge and refining your techniques allows you to adapt to new challenges and opportunities. Expert resources, such as those from Collin Seow Trading Academy, can provide valuable insights and reinforce systematic trading methods.
Don’t overlook the importance of psychological resilience. Managing emotions and maintaining discipline are just as critical as technical skills. Use your review process to identify emotional triggers that may cloud your judgement, and create specific rules to counteract these tendencies.
Think of your trading plan as a “living document” – one that grows and evolves with your experience and understanding of the market. By combining systematic evaluation, disciplined execution, and a commitment to learning, you’ll build a plan that adapts to Singapore’s dynamic financial markets and sets the foundation for consistent trading success.
FAQs
How often should I review and adjust my trading plan for better results?
To keep your trading plan working effectively, it’s important to review and adjust it on a regular basis. How often you do this depends on your trading style and the level of market activity you’re dealing with. For instance, daily reviews can help you make quick tweaks to stay on track, while weekly reviews give you the chance to spot patterns and evaluate your short-term performance. A more in-depth monthly review is perfect for assessing your overall strategy and making bigger adjustments if needed.
It’s also wise to revisit your plan after any major market shifts or at least once or twice a year. This ensures your plan stays aligned with current market conditions. Keeping your trading plan updated is crucial for staying organised and maintaining consistent results.
What is the difference between backtesting and forward testing, and why are they essential for evaluating a trading strategy?
Backtesting is all about putting your trading strategy to the test using historical market data. By doing this, you can get a sense of how your approach might have worked in the past, uncovering its strengths, spotting weaknesses, and identifying areas that could use some tweaking.
Forward testing takes a different angle. It evaluates your strategy in real-time or through simulated live trading. This method shows how your strategy holds up under current market conditions, often revealing challenges that backtesting alone might miss.
Both methods play a key role in crafting a well-rounded trading plan. Backtesting helps you fine-tune your strategy efficiently, while forward testing ensures it’s ready to handle the unpredictability of live markets. When used together, they give traders the confidence to make smarter decisions and manage risks more effectively.
How can I use a trading journal to improve my trading performance effectively?
To boost your trading performance using a trading journal, start by keeping a detailed record of every trade. Note down important details like your entry and exit points, the reasoning behind the trade, and even your emotions at the time. This helps you map out your decision-making process clearly.
Make it a habit to review your journal regularly. This allows you to spot patterns, fine-tune your strategies, and identify areas where you might be going wrong. By analysing trends in your successful trades and recognising where adjustments are needed, you can gradually make smarter, data-backed improvements to your trading approach. The key is to stay disciplined and consistent in updating your journal – it’s a crucial step towards achieving long-term success.
